Hello everyone,
I am currently modeling a masonry vaulted bridge as a 2D model (simplified micromodel). The stones are modeled as linear-elastic surfaces, and the mortar joints as line releases.
For the release in the local z-direction uz, I have defined "Partial Effect" (see image 1):
- Tension: failure from 0.05 kN/m (simulation of the missing tensile strength / joint opens)
- Compression: yielding from 4090 kN/m
This works flawlessly for almost all joints. However, for the critical, most highly loaded joints, I am getting illogical result patterns (see image 2):
Over about half the length of the joint, a positive deformation uz occurs (the joint opens up to approx. 0.3 mm). However, in the same area, the force vz curve still shows compressive forces instead of dropping to 0 kN/m. Furthermore, the compressive force curve exhibits an unnatural kink exactly where the joint begins to open.
My questions about this:
- Could this be a display issue in RFEM 6?
- Did I possibly make a conceptual error when defining the line release?
- How can I adjust the model so that when the displacement uz > 0, the compressive force becomes physically correctly exactly zero?
Hi awsassagier,
Thank you for your message!
To analyze the problem more precisely, the model file would be very helpful:
Click on File → Save As and choose the following settings to reduce the file size:

image467×393 8.19 KB
Then upload the file here (e.g. *.rf6, *.rs9) – this way the community can also contribute to the solution.
Don't want to share the file publicly? No problem – send it to me via direct message: click on my profile picture or my username → Message.
Best regards
Matthias
"Hello Matthias,
Thank you very much for the quick response and your willingness to help!
I have saved the file as requested without results and attached it here.
The described phenomenon (gaping joint uz > 0, but still compressive force vz) is particularly clearly visible at line no. [34] under the load combination [LC7].
I am very curious about your analysis, whether this is a numerical smearing effect or if I can still fine-tune the parameters.
Best regards!"
FEM-Brücke.rf6 (1.5 MB)
Hi awsassagier,
The releases are correctly set and work as expected. The kink occurs because the force distribution over the two endpoints of each FE (finite element) element is linearized according to the FE method.
At the node inside the joint, the force v_z = 0 (failure). At the node outside the joint, the compressive force v_z < 0. These two points are linearly connected in your diagram.
A finer mesh should better represent the behavior.
If you have any further questions, feel free to get in touch.
Best regards,
Matthias